MY PERSONAL DENTAL TRAGEDY

 

My friends feel that going public with the dental work that was done to me by these local dentists is a “double edged sword”.  They are concerned that I will not be able to find an honest dentist to work in my mouth and if I do find one, they may be afraid to work in my mouth and assume the liability of trying to reconstruct / repair the damage that I am left with.  An honest dentist may be uncomfortable with the fact that I have publicized what was done to my mouth.

 

My friends may be right and yes, I will require extensive dental procedures for the rest of my life due to these dentists performing excessive, unnecessary and poorly planned dental work in my mouth.  In my opinion, these dentists did not allow me the opportunity to give “informed consent” on their dental work and acknowledge and accept the risks involved.

 

I feel that the public has a right to know what can happen in dental treatments and they need to be extremely cautious.  I cannot stress enough the need for “informed consent” regarding any dental procedure.

 

Notwithstanding that I may have difficulty finding an honest dentist to help me with the permanent damage that I have been subjected to, I do believe that there are some honest, ethical and skilled dental professionals in South Florida that practice through genuine conviction and can and will help me. I have met several since I left the care of the four dentists that destroyed my healthy teeth.

 

 

I am so embarrassed and ashamed that I have been put in this position.  It took me more than 1 year to even start to address the totality of what was done to my mouth.  Emotionally, I was damaged and could not address what I was facing.

 

I believed what Dr. Tolley and Dr. Blake told me regarding “future jaw problems and that I needed to fill-in my missing tooth that had never developed (grown in)” and I trusted them.  I am college educated and have had extensive experience in medical procedures with my sister (heart transplant in 1985) and my son’s cancer.

 

My biggest downfall / fear is to have a medical problem.  I practice preventative healthcare religiously.  I do not want to get sick.  I am a single, no family near and although I have friends that anyone would envy, I value my independence to the highest degree.  I strongly believe in “quality of life and not quantity”.

 

I make a living, but I am not rich.  A few years back, I was a single mother, I took full responsibility for my actions, ended up homeless and a woman took me into her home and heart.  She allowed me to evolve out of this tragedy with grace and dignity.  Unfortunately, my son had a malignant brain tumor and died.

 

I completely bottomed out financially (no income or child support) and it took some time to get back on my feet.  But I did it and I did not claim personal bankruptcy.

 

A few life lessons were learned and decisions made.  I do not want to be sick.  I spent 6 weeks living in-patient at Hospice on 45th Street with my son and they were absolutely incredible.  I could never give enough praise or gratitude for the support they gave me. 

 

I also learned that I need a few dollars in my pocket just in case.  I value and respect money and spend it wisely.

 

 

 

The last 10 years of my life have focused on preventative healthcare (diet, exercise and dietary food supplements).  I also do not drink, smoke or take drugs. 

 

Since my dental work has been done I was given Xanax (anti-anxiety) medication by Dr. Mohaupt to take at night so I would not clench my teeth over the bridgework.  I was given Hydrocodone (did not work for me and I returned them to Dr. Blake – as noted in his records) and Percocets for pain (I quarter the Percocets and they work well.  If I take an entire pill, I throw up). 

 

Before the Percocets, I would take anywhere from 7-8 Aleve pills at a time for pain daily in my mouth (you should only take 2, but this would not stop my pain).   I took so many Aleves that my stomach burned and I had a surgeon perform an “endoscopic viewing procedure” to assess the damage. 

 

I also had to see a cardiologist for panic attacks.  If I had to see a dentist or even think about what these dentists did to me, my heart would race (it felt like it was pounding out of my chest and I had trouble breathing).  The stress from losing my teeth also caused my hair to fall out in patches (this has happened before when my father and son died).

 

I began having adverse reactions to the Xanax and I stopped taking it (.025 mg before I went to bed– I was breaking it in half) because it is a “downer” and should not be used on a regular basis.  I feel Xanax is an effective drug for anxiety when you experience it (you need to take it at the time), but you should not take it regularly. 

 

Dr. Blake gave me my last 18 Percocets in March 2003 and I still have 4 left as of Ocober 1, 2004.

 

My ethics are such that I am not looking for favors or a free ride.  I prefer to do the right thing and hope others do the same.  It takes less effort to be decent, fair and responsible than to be a low life.

 

I strongly believe that living in America that there is no need to take advantage or be opportunistic at another’s expense in order to make a living.

 

It is everyone’s legal and ethical right to give “informed consent” with respect to any medical or dental procedure being done to him or her.

 

I can assure you that an individual with 50% mental capacity would not have allowed these dentists to perform these procedures on them if they were given the opportunity of “informed consent”.  If all the pros and cons had been explained this dental work would never have been undertaken by anyone.

 

In my opinion, the dental procedures that were done to myself were done strictly for these dentists’ monetary gain and for no other reason.  I am now condemned to a life of pain and suffering, physically, mentally and financially in order for these dentists to make a living.

 

What happened to the do no harm on a patient?  In my opinion, these dentists need to mislead patients and perform excessive work in order to pay their bills and support their lifestyles.

 

Examples of “informed consent”

 

I had a c-section with my son.  I am cut from pelvic bone to pelvic bone.  My incision bulges on the left side and I have a lot of internal scar tissue.  The internal ridges were causing me pain when I did “belly postures” in yoga.  As well, I am not “too pretty” with my pants off.  I made an appointment with a well-known Plastic Surgery Group in Palm Springs in 1999. 

 

I met with 3 surgeons and they explained that in order to repair this damage, it would require extensive surgery (removal of scar tissue, tummy tuck and reconstruction).  They explained that the surgical risk was serious.  They strongly advised me to take the time to really consider the risks and advised me to not do the postures in yoga that hurt me.  I took their advice and choose to not do this surgery.  These professional surgeons did their job and allowed me the right to make an “informed consent”.

 

I also use Retin-A Gel for acne on my face.  I am well aware of the “increased” risks of skin cancer in using this product.  I always wear a hat and sunscreen and if I do get skin cancer, I cannot blame anyone other than myself.  I am aware of the risk and I accept responsibility for it.

 

 

Do these dentists that performed these excessive and expensive dental procedures on myself care?  No.  Dr. Blake had the nerve to say to me “it is your fault that you broke your 5- unit bridge and fractured your teeth.  You grind your teeth and you cannot help it”.  In my opinion, Dr. Blake is a greedy, manipulative and sad excuse for a human being.  There was no humane or ethical treatment shown towards myself nor was any thought given to my future dental care or possible end result.   

 

I did some research on the Palm Beach County Clerk’s website (www.pbcountyclerk.com).  Dr. Blake went through a divorce a couple of years ago and the records I printed out from the website show between alimony and child support he has come up with $5,000 + /month.  He even had to pay his ex-wife’s attorney $20,000 in legal fees.  In my opinion, I cannot imagine Dr. Blake making enough money filling teeth or single tooth crown restorations to cover this.  He needs the income from multiple unit bridgework and dentures. 

 

Let’s face it, dental health is improving and there will be fewer and fewer patients requiring dentures. 

 

FACT

If at age 33 I was a teeth grinder “bruxism”, this would have shown as wear and tear on my teeth and should have been considered in any dental treatment / procedure (informed consent / pros and cons of dental treatment).

A dentist never told me “you grind your teeth”.  These remarks were made after this 5-unit bridge was installed.

 

Note:

I did have 2 bite guards made (not by Dr. Blake’s office) – upper and lower out of plastic (they were not the thick acrylic splints).  I preferred wearing the upper.

The splint/bite guard that I wear at night now is very thick and uncomfortable.  You cannot close your mouth together.  The pain in my jaw from TMJ is unbelievable and I am afraid not to wear it because I do not want my top teeth falling out. Now my top teeth on the upper left have dropped down because I had not been given an upper orthodontic appliance. 

 

Note: As of January '05: I wear an upper orthodontic appliance ant it feels much better.

It took me 1.5 years to commit to allowing Dr. Blake to install a 5-unit bridge in my mouth at a cost of $4,800.  Dr. Blake even sent a letter to Dr. Tolley telling him I could not afford this bridge.

 

Dr. Blake never told me that filing down 4 healthy teeth for his “elaborate bridge design”, which was being done to prevent future jaw problems that I could end up with a root canal.  I actually ended up with 2 root canals.  Root canals cause the treated teeth to become brittle, which make them more susceptible to fracturing.  I just recently found out that another tooth that was part of his elaborate bridge design has died from the trauma of the bridge breaking.  It is abscessed and a root canal may save it or it may need to be removed.  This is still being determined.

 

You don’t suppose Dr. Blake accidentally overlooked this risk of root canals or God forbid considered that with the natural movement in my jaw that the bridge could actually break?  Root canals were never even mentioned before he performed his “dental treatment”.  He now claims to the Florida Department of Health that he had “extensive discussions with me regarding the risks involved and that I probably would end up with root canals”.  This is not true. 

 

I told Dr. Blake that I could not afford $4,800 for his “bridge”.  If he also told me “add another $1,800 for root canals” can he convince anyone that I agreed to this? 

 

In fact, if the risk for root canals was so imminent as per Blake’s letter to the Department of Health, why did he not send me to an Endodontist for a consultation prior to exposing me to this risk and prior to installing his elaborate 5-unit bridge and destroying 4 healthy teeth (2 teeth fractured when his bridge broke and were removed and 1 tooth has died and also abscessed from trauma)?

   

Dr. Blake left me in temporary teeth for 7 months while he perfected his 5- unit bridge.   No one should be left in temporary crowned teeth for 7 months.  They do not fit properly and do cause loss of bone around the teeth.  As well, every time Dr. Blake removed my temporary crowns to try on the porcelain crowns, my bite needed to be adjusted again. 

 

 

 

I saw in my file from Dr. Blake’s office that he wrote a letter to Dr. Tolley on May 24, 1999 stating “my teeth would be difficult to prepare for a fixed partial denture…… teeth #21, 20, 19 are mobile and need to be stabilized with a fixed splint for at least 3 months….” (Copy of actual letter under Blake’s name). 

 

Note:  I was never copied on any of these letters nor did Dr. Blake or Dr. Tolley discuss these letters with me? Is their "good 'ole boy" network again?

 

This was the first I had even heard this terminology concerning my teeth.  In my opinion, this letter was fabricated after I reported these dentists to the Florida Department of Health between Dr. Blake and Dr. Tolley.  If Dr. Tolley received this letter, why did he not give me a copy or at least discuss it with me.  Keep in mind, these dentists know each other well and refer patients regularly.   In my opinion, they certainly never had my best interest in the forefront. 

 

Dr. Blake did tell me “the orthodontics were not finished – the teeth were not rotated properly”.  If there was even a 5% risk factor in performing bridge work in my mouth, I had the right to know it and give an informed decision to either participate in his “recommended dental treatment” or not.

 

If in fact my teeth were still mobile 6 months after the braces were removed (Dr. Tolley and Dr. McCrannel made the decision to remove them 1.5 years after installation), maybe that was a good indicator that they should not be performing “bridge work”.  Another retainer could have been made or they could have re-installed metal braces to stabilize the teeth.  Dr. Blake never said to me during consultation that my “teeth were still mobile”. 

 

Stabilizing my teeth (if that was the problem) should have been done with a retainer or metal braces, not a 5-unit bridge.   That would have been in my best interest, rather than filing down 4 healthy teeth with a procedure that carried significant risk.

 

Dr. Blake installed his “elaborate 5-unit bridge 1.5 years after he wrote this letter to Dr. Tolley.  Were my teeth stabilized then?   I did not see any letters concerning this in their files.

 

 

I want the public to know what was done to myself and what my future entails.  Why “informed consent is vital and how important and critical it is to treat with honest and competent dental professionals that will explain all aspects of any dental procedure (the good, the bad and the worst case scenarios).  It is vital that you get detailed informed consent in writing.

 

 

I am a survivor and I will survive this.  I do not want anyone else in this situation.   I will put a face on dental greed and bad dentistry.

 

 

Brief Summary of Events with Dentists

(You can click on the menu to the left on Each Dentist Name for records, receipts and correspondence)

 

 

 

 

TEETH HISTORY – Elaine Prentice – 1996 to Present

                                                                                                                       

1996  -- Dr. Tolley – General Dentist

 

I went to Dr. Tolley to have a single crown repaired on a front tooth.  The prior dentist had a temporary crown fabricated that was too short and needed to be replaced and the metal pin had been broken.  Dr. Tolley sent me to Dr. Mohaupt to remove the broken metal pin.

 

Dr. Tolley did a beautiful job in repairing my tooth.

 

Although, his crown has certainly taken a beating now with the splint / bite guard I have to wear at night in order to keep my top teeth from falling out.

 

1997

 

Dr. Leonard Tolley recommended several times (every time I went to his office) that I needed to have the space on the lower left jaw filled in.   He insisted that I would have problems with my jaw as I aged if the space was not filled in– I was 33 years old at the time

He said I needed braces first to close the teeth together and create 1 large space

 

Note:  this was not done for cosmetic purpose – you could not see it

I was not having any problems or pain and was not bothered by the space – I could eat and no one noticed it and I never felt it was a problem.  This particular tooth had never grown in (genetics?).

 

In my opinion, Dr. Tolley knew that I was the type of person that was very concerned about my teeth (I clean my teeth every 3-4 months) and played on this by making me fearful for my jaw.  This bridge would have netted him approx. $3,000.  Unfortunately, I was not smart enough to figure this out.

 

He referred me to Dr. McCranel’s and Dr. Esser’s Office for the braces.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sept 1997Dr. Tolley & Dr. McCrannel

Dr. Tolley and Dr. McCrannel spoke and Dr. Tolley told him how to move the teeth for his 3-unit bridge.  The lower braces were installed to move teeth back and front and create one large space – Approx. $3,000.

 

I am not completely excusing Dr. McCrannel for his involvement in moving my teeth, however, I did hear Dr. Tolley tell him how he wanted the teeth moved so he could install the 3-unit bridge.

 

I have now been told by other dentists that the teeth should not have been moved the way they were (rotations were not completed), if at all.  The braces were not necessary and I should not have been subjected to this work (forget the pain and suffering of having my teeth moved). In my opinion, Dr. McCramel should also have known better.

 

 

December 1998Dr. McCrannel

The braces were removed and a retainer was made. 

 

Dr. Tolley informed me that he was “not comfortable in trying to install a bridge here” after he had me do this work with the braces in order to prep for the bridge. 

 

In my opinion, Dr. Tolley was not qualified to be undertaking or orchestrating this type of reconstructive work nor qualified to be instructing an orthodontist on how to move my teeth.  It is obvious that Dr. Tolley did not have a clue on what he was proposing or how to achieve it.

 

In fact, he had models of my mouth (which I paid for).  You would think that some thought was given to how the teeth would be positioned after the braces were removed and how a bridge would fit and function in this new space?  I would have been better off taking my models to a carpenter for a projected end result.  A carpenter would have had the skill to be able to project a finished product structurally.

 

I saw 3 dentists for restoration work (Dr. Tolley recommended Dr. Blake)

I saw another 2 dentists (1 oral surgeon) regarding a dental implant (I was not a candidate because of bone loss and location on jaw – too difficult to work with and the nerve in my jaw is too close and I could lose permanent sensation in my jaw)

 

 

 

May 19th and September 23rd 1999 – Dr. Blake

He recommended a 5-unit bridge                       -- $4,800

I told him that I could not afford this (he sent a letter to Dr. Tolley telling him this)

I even told Dr. Blake that if this is what I need (bridge) I might have to have it done in Canada (my family lives there)

 

Dr. Blake also emphasized that as I aged, my jaw would have problems with this space open and that my teeth would keep moving

He also said a 3 unit bridge would not work – it would not have enough support and would break

I did ask for a removable appliance

Dr. Blake did not recommend any kind of removable appliance nor did he suggest just leaving the space alone

He also did not advise of any risks associated with this type of extensive bridgework or the liability of filing down 4 healthy teeth “don’t worry – I do this all the time” is what he told me

 

It took me 1.5 years to commit to this bridge (I kept wearing my retainer at night).  I was worried financially and I was concerned about filing down 4 healthy teeth.

Dr. Blake assured me that it was “no big deal” – he does this all the time”

In my opinion Dr. Blake recommended this bridge because he needed the money

He did not advise me that there could be problems (i.e. Breakage, root canals, future care, etc.)

I would never have done this bridge work, forget orthodontics had this dental work been explained to me in it’s entirety (full disclosure)

 

Dr. Blake was supposedly at the top of his game and I trusted and believed in him and look at my mouth now and the teeth that have been lost.  Look at what I will need to go through to try and keep my remaining teeth and restore stability to the lower left jaw.

 

Note:

My mouth does not respond well to local anesthesia.  In fact, you can see in my file with Dr. Blake that it takes anywhere from 3-8 needles to keep me numb.  This is so painful and this what my future entails.

 

Feb 23rd  2000 – Dr. Blake

 

5-unit Bridge was placed – temporary teeth

 

It felt awkward and a lot of pain to the back 2 teeth --- I now understand that my bite was not right

 

March 3rd  2000 – Dr. Blake

 

Pain in back 2 teeth

 

 

March 14th 2000 – Dr. Mohaupt – Endodontist –

Root canal (back tooth) $765

 

Note:  no adjustment was made to the bite to try and alleviate the pressure on these back 2 teeth in order to prevent a root canal

 

Xanax was recommended to stop me from clenching down on this bridge?  I don’t suppose the bridge design had anything to do with my bite?  I also want to emphasize that the “weight” of this bridge was significantly more than my natural healthy teeth.  No dentist explained this either.

 

Note:

Dr. Mohaupt’s file did have a notation questioning “Blake’s bridge” could be the cause of the root canals.  It does not reference specifics.  Dr. Mohaupt never said anything to me about it.

 

 

May 10th  2000 – Dr. Mohaupt -- Root canal on second back tooth - $915

 

Note: Dr. Mohaupt did no follow up on these root canals (no x-rays) nor did Dr. Blake ever take an x-ray after the bridge was installed.  I have now learned that this type of follow up should be done regularly for root canals and bridgework.

 

 

 

 

Bridge Fittings and Adjustments

 

My bridge was fitted and adjusted 11 times with Dr. Blake (see his records).

 

 

Dental Cleanings

 

I had my teeth cleaned 7 times at Dr. Blake’s office and the only x-rays (bite-wings were done on October 2, 2002).

 

Note:  Bite Wing X-rays  -- they only show the crowns of the teeth.  They do not display the roots!

 

 

 

 

July 15, 2002 – Dr. Blake

Lower back right molar – filling replaced with mercury amalgam (big filling)

It affected my bite and the tooth ached

 

July 31, 2002 – Dr. Blake

He adjusted the bite (took some of the filling off)

No work was done to check the bite in my mouth around the new filling or bridgework. 

 

August 2, 2002 – I awoke a 2:00 am  (less than 32 hours after adjustment)

I heard a breaking noise and my lower teeth hurt

I took a handful of Aleves

 

I thought I needed to have my bite adjusted again

 

August 7th, 2002 – Dr. Gleiber – no charge

My friend called who worked for Dr. Gleiber to bring her something at the office

She insisted that Dr. Gleiber look at my teeth because I told her I still had pain and that I would try and see Dr. Blake that day for another adjustment

 

Dr. Gleiber took an x-ray of the area and said both teeth had tremendous bone loss and were abscessed and I also had bone loss on the tooth attached to the bridge.  He wanted to know when x-rays had been taken?  I informed him that none were taken of the ceramic bridge after placement.

 

He called Blake’s office (he was on vacation)

 

August 12th 2002 – Dr. Blake

He called and told me that it was possible that the root canals had failed and that he wanted me to see Dr. Mohaupt to explore if there was a leakage

 

 

 

August 14th   2002– Dr. Mohaupt

I saw him and he determined that he would open the root canal on the inside tooth and explore it

Dr. Mohaupt tried to tell me that he sent a “reminder notice” for me to come back for follow up after the root canals.  I never received a notice or a phone call.  I would have gone to the appointment – I had too much invested financially not to follow up.

 

August 21st  2002– Dr. Mohaupt – no charge

Opened the root canal on the 2nd back tooth

He determined that I had broke (cracked/fractured) roots of 2 teeth and recommended I see Dr. Blake

He did not charge me he said “out of empathy”

 

August 22nd  2002– Dr. Blake

Dr. Blake called me at home and told me I had to have both teeth surgically removed and recommended Dr. Richard Kaplan (oral surgeon)

I never saw Dr. Blake in his office after his bridge broke until the teeth were surgically removed.

 

August 26th 2002– Dr. Kaplan  - $150

Dr. Kaplan reviewed my teeth and set surgery for next day

 

August 27th 2002-  Dr. Kaplan  - $1,125

I was sedated and he cut the bridge and surgically removed the 2 back molars and cleaned up the infection in my jawbone

He told me that there was no way to place bone around the outside of the tooth attached to the bridge – I would probably end up over time losing it as well

 

September 9th 2002– Dr. Blake

He looked at the surgery site to determine if he could make impressions for an acrylic splint/bite guard to wear in the lower jaw in order to prevent loss of the upper teeth (they need to touch something or they will fall out)

 

He blamed the bridge breaking on me “grinding my teeth and that I should not feel “bad, it happens”.  I never had a problem with teeth grinding until this excessive and unnecessary dental work was undertaken.  I allowed Blake to manipulate and convince me that this was my fault that his bridge broke.  It took a long time, but my opinion changed when I started seeing other dentists and viewing their reactions.

 

Keep in mind, throughout the course of allowing Dr. Blake to work in my mouth (February 2000 to March 2003) I worshipped the ground he walked on.  In fact, even when I was getting other opinions, I still wanted to defend him.  I could not wrap my mind around the dental work that he had done to my mouth and the risk that he exposed me to.  In my opinion, Dr. Blake knew better, and if he does not, then he should not be licensed.

 

Dr. Blake saw how if suffered through his 5-unit bridge.  Dr. Blake has 2 daughters and I often wonder how he would feel if something like this was done to them.  I am someone’s daughter too.

 

 

September 12th 2002– Dr. Blake

He took impressions for an acrylic splint / bite guard

 

 

October 8th 2002– Dr. Blake  - $275 for splint/bite guard (he charged me ½ of $550 – his normal cost for a splint /bite guard)

My splint / bite guard was fitted

 

October 10th 2002– Dr. Blake

He bonded a tooth I had chipped on right upper tooth and placed some bonding material on the upper left tooth

 

 

October 15th 2002– Dr. Blake

Adjusted splint / bite guard and recommended Dr. Kaplan for implants.  He told me that he would place 2 implants and cantilever a fake tooth.  I asked him about a removable appliance and he said, “You will never wear it” and “you do not have anything to attach it to”

 

Why did he ever recommend a 5-unit bridge and destroy 4 teeth to do it?  Why did he not even suggest just crowning the back 2 teeth with a cantilever in the first place instead of a 5-unit bridge?  Or better yet, nothing at all.

 

October 16th 2002– Dr. Kaplan

Discussed placing 2 implants

 

 

 

October 31st 2002 Dr. Blake

Adjusted splint / bite guard (hurting lower back teeth on right side)

 

November 27th 2002– Dr. Kaplan - $4,000

I was sedated and 2 implants were placed (they were placed in the same space where my natural teeth were removed?)  I am still not sure who made this decision (Kaplan or Blake) with respect to restoring this side of my mouth?  Other dentists have questioned why these implants were placed in these areas for a successful restoration and why the back implant in particular was not placed deeper into my jawbone and why was this type of implant used (particular brand and size)?

 

Keep in mind that the implants were placed in the same space as my own teeth were.  The reason for all this dental work in the first place, as directed by Dr. Tolley and Dr. Blake, was to correct the spacing of my teeth to prevent future jaw problems! 

 

December 4th 2002– Dr. Kaplan

Looked at surgery site and I did not see him again until I discovered that the bone had not grown on inside of back tooth

 

December 11th 2002– Dr. Blake

Adjusted splint / bite guard – hurting lower back teeth

 

December 17th 2002– Dr. Kaplan (3 weeks after implants were placed)

 

I called his office because implant area was hurting and spoke with an Assistant

I told them that the gum tissue on the back implant had opened up and the implant was completely exposed

His assistant (Karen) said she spoke with Dr. Kaplan and he said not to “worry about it” – I could hear her speaking with him in the background.

Now there is no bone growth on this inside area (cupping)– In my opinion and I have been told by other dentists (periodontists) that this bone did not grow in due to bacteria; the surgery site was left unprotected. 

 

Surprisingly enough, even the State’s dental expert, Dr. Ferris, said, “this should have been addressed and treated with antibiotic powders to prevent the cupping and to try and stimulate the bone to grow”.

 

Addressing this problem 3 months later is useless.  Keep in mind; the mouth is the dirtiest area in the body for bad bacteria

 

Note:  Dr. Kaplan’s attorney sent my dental records and guess what, there is literature stating that “the implants need to be kept covered for at least 3 months for effective healing and integration into the jawbone.”  View under Kaplan's link

 

Dr. Blake also knew and saw on several occasions that this back implant was uncovered.  Let me guess, he skipped this section along with Dr. Kaplan of the course on successful implant restoration as well?

 

 

December 19th 2002– Dr. Blake

Adjusted splint / bite guard – hurting lower back teeth

 

 

 

January 22nd 2003 – Dr. Blake

Teeth cleaning

Adjust splint/bite guard – hurting lower back teeth

 

 

 

March 14th 2003– Dr. Blake

I told him that Dr. Kaplan’s office was calling to schedule the appointment to uncover the 1 implant that the tissue was still covering and place the abutments for the crowns (I have no idea what this would have cost).

 

I was not confident that the back implant was healed because I still had sensation there (the back implant was completely uncovered since 3 weeks after placement)

Dr. Blake also knew that this implant was uncovered and should have known that there was a risk with leaving this surgery site unprotected / open

 

I had Dr. Blake look at the implants and take an x-ray to make sure they were ok

He determined that the bone did not grow on the inside of the back implant

He told me to see Dr. Kaplan and he would send him a copy of his x-ray

He adjusted my splint/bite guard (hurting top teeth)

I told Dr. Blake that I was not dealing with this well

Dr. Blake said to me “what is acceptable to you – 80% success rate on the implants?” 

 

 

March 21st 2003– Dr. Kaplan

He reviewed the previous panoramic x-ray taken after the implants were placed with the new x-ray from Dr. Blake (keep in mind that panoramic x-rays are not as defined / detailed as a regular x-ray)

Dr. Kaplan said I had no bone loss – the bone just did not grow in this area

He recommended a bone graft with artificial bone (some type of bovine) mixed with my bone – which I now understand has a very low success rate in this particular application, but is useful for generating money and covering office overhead (I have no idea with this would have cost)

 

Dr. Kaplan said that because the tissue did not cover the back implant (like the front implant) that it had nothing to do with the bone not growing.  I do not believe this nor do other dentists. 

 

 

 

 

 

Note: 

I made an appointment with Dr. Stuart Feldman (Periodontist) on April 21, 2003 to review the implant site for a bone graft (I cancelled on the advice of a general dentist in Pompano to not see anyone in West Palm Beach that Dr. Blake was associated with at this time).  When I told Dr. Blake that I had made an appointment with Dr. Feldman for another opinion, he said, “Can I call him and discuss your dental work?”  I am sure he instructed Dr. Feldman what he could and could not say – I am glad now that I cancelled the appointment but I sincerely regret that Dr. Feldman was not chosen as the dentist to place my implants.

 

Also, I have been asked several times why Dr. Blake did not have Dr. Feldman place my implants.  He was more experienced in implant surgery than Dr. Kaplan.  In fact, I have been told that he was involved with his partner Dr. Lazerra, in the design of an actual implant.  I do remember Dr. Blake telling me that he did not send me to Dr. Feldman because he does not have the “best bedside manner”.  I was sedated and it would not have mattered.  After everything I had been through, I deserved the best and most experienced dentist in placing implants.  I also deserved to have a thorough plan on how to restore my missing teeth that Dr. Blake’s bridge destroyed.   I cannot seem to find one in my records.  Is the dental treatment / plan conveniently missing?  Was a comprehensive treatment / plan ever made?  Did these dentists nonchalantly come up with something while having lunch?

 

 

March 24th 2003– Dr. Blake

I told him that I did not care about the implants at this time

I wanted my top teeth saved, pain free and stabilized and asked him to make some type of splint/bite guard for the top teeth so I could wear 2 splint/bite guards at night

 

I thought he was going to make me an upper bite guard because my top teeth hurt

 

When I got in the chair, Dr. Blake told me that he was going to make my temporary teeth and place them

He removed the gum tissue from the inside tooth (the back tooth was already uncovered since December)

He placed something in the teeth and took impressions

I asked Dr. Blake why Dr. Kaplan was not doing this and he said, “I don’t need him to do this”

 

I had no idea that you are not able to wear two acrylic splint/bite guards at the same time  -- they are rather bulky?

 

I also asked him about making some sort of a retainer for the bottom

 

Dr. Blake told me “I will try and make what ever you want, however, at this time I can only place the temporary teeth and the space will stay

If you want a bone graft – this can be done later”

 

 

 

 

April 2nd 2003

 

Upper teeth were hurting bad and they were moving (loose) from hitting the splint/bite guard (usually splint/bite guards are placed on the upper teeth not the lower)

I called to get an appointment with Dr. Blake

 

 

 

 

 

April 9th 2003– Dr. Blake - $500 for another splint / bite guard (I never had it fitted or picked it up – guess what – he kept the money)

 

I told him I did not want him inserting these “temporary crowns for the implants” at this time

 

 

 

April 16th – Dr. Scharf – no charge

I got an appointment with my friend’s general dentist in Ft. Lauderdale

He reviewed my mouth and said that there was nothing he could do for me

He recommended I see a Dr. Yockus-Prosthodontist in Ft. Lauderdale

He did not want to talk to me about what I felt had happened with my bite and breaking the bridge or why this 5-unit bridge was installed to begin with

 

 

April 23rd – Dr. Sean Yockus – $119

He reviewed my mouth

He was not impressed with the implants or where they were placed

Recommended that at this point to place temporary teeth with a cantilever on the inside one and see what happens

He said he did not know if I could get 1 week or 1 year out of these implants

He was surprised that the surgeon did not follow up after 6-8 weeks or try to cover up the surgery site to keep it protected

He would not bone graft around the inside of the implant because after this length of time – the chance of success is very low – he could not believe that this was even suggested??

He would not discuss with me the placement of the initial 5- unit bridge or filling done on right side – this made him very uncomfortable

He told me that the goal in dentistry is to “not encumber other teeth”

I tried “very hard” to pin him down on what was done to me by these dentists and he did great job of “side stepping” my questions

He knew the office where I was treated (Dr. Keough and Dr. Kay) but did not know Dr. Blake

I asked him to make me something removable and he said “you are too young and I am not going to do this for you”

 

April 25, 2003

I saw Dr. Blake and told him I had seen Dr. Yockus

I relayed that he was not impressed with my implants – however, because they are there - he would place temporary teeth with a cantilever on the inside one and see what happens

Dr. Blake said he would not fill in the space because he feels it will be too much of a load on the back implant

 

May 2nd, 2003 – Dr. Gleiber

 

I had my teeth cleaned and a full set of x-rays were taken

 

Dr. Gleiber said little, other than “you have started with these implants and should go forward”.  He also did not want to comment on the work that had been done to me, other than to say, “why were these implants positioned this way” and who made the decision for the restoration?”  I did not know and still do not know even after going through my medical records from Dr. Blake and Dr. Kaplan.  This information appears to be “missing”.

He saw how upset (emotional) and fearful I was for restoration on these implants and recommended another opinion and suggested completing the restoration with another implant so that I could have 3 separate units and not encumber them.

 

Dr. Gleiber referred me to Dr. Gutteriez of Florida Institute for Periodontics and Dental Implants.

 

 

May 7th – Dr. Gutteriez – Periodontist - $65

He reviewed my mouth and recommended the following

The back implant with a “clinical exam” does appear to be solid, but does not “sound” the same as the inside one

There is less bone growth and the bone is not as “dense”

There cannot be a successful result/restoration with just these 2 implants.  They will not withstand loading for any significant period of time

I also understood from our conversation that even if there was enough bone around the back implant, you could not successfully restore the 2 teeth with a cantilever for a significant period of time

He also told me that it is not smart to ever bridge implants to a “living tooth” because the implants “titanium screws that are integrated into my jaw bone” do not move and natural teeth do

Trying to bone graft around the back implant as suggested by Dr. Kaplan would not be successful and a waste of money.

 

He recommended:

Place 2 temporary teeth with a cantilever on the inside one (both implants would be splinted) and this would give me some function now to stabilize my bite.  Place the occlusion on the back tooth and get the bone graft done immediately and see if it works (my bone mixed with bovine protein).

He told me I could not bite nor chew on this side of my mouth.

 

If the bone graft is successful, then insert 1 more implant on the inside in order to give me 3 implants to spread the load, and let the 3 implants function separately.

 

I am not saying his recommendation is wrong, however, I not willing to try and bone graft and place another implant.  Due to the proximity of the nerve in my jaw and the possibility of losing permanent sensation in my jaw, I feel the risk is too great and I do not have the confidence to take this on.

 

Note:

I saw in my file that Dr. Blake had a copy of Dr. Gutteriez’ report on when I sought his opinion.  I never gave permission to Dr. Gutteriez or his office to discuss my dental visit or forward my records with Dr. Blake (I was no longer treating with Dr. Blake).  How legal is this? According to Dr Gutierrez's lawyer, I have no rights with respect to this office giving out my medical records. In my opinion, it is very small community here and it certainly seems as though these dentists stick together and support each other.  I am terrific evidence of these actions.

 

FACT

 

I know that after all the research I have done now, that a bridge (3 or 5-units) was not the right thing to do on any level.  In my opinion, it was a source of income for Dr. Tolley and Dr. Blake.  It was over kill for something that was not causing me pain.

 

It destroyed 4 healthy teeth and I would have preferred something removable if I had known the risks or just let the space go back to the way it was.  I was not in pain until this excessive work was done.  I now have pain everyday of my life!  My only reason for fixing this space was to prevent any future problems with my jaw, as I was directed and convinced of by Dr. Tolley and Dr. Blake.   It was not for esthetics.  You could not see it.   Also, why would they not crown the back 2 teeth and place a cantilever tooth in the space? I never had a problem with grinding my teeth either until after the bridge was placed.  I never had any dentist tell me that “you grind your teeth”.

 

In my opinion, Dr. Blake did this 5-unit bridge for the money only.  No concern was given to my future or long-term dental work/care.  He did not tell me that there were risks and that I could possibly lose the teeth, or that I could even end up with root canals.  Dr. Blake was legally and ethically obligated to disclose all risks to myself and obtain my informed consent.

 

He told me when I met him that “he did this all the time”.  I also remember asking him after the bridge was placed – how long would it last (I was referring to the crowns)?  He just shook his head and said, “he did not know”.

 

Where are these dentists’ ethics here?  What happened to do no harm?

 

I do not think that I broke the bridge because I grinded my teeth.  I woke up less than 48 hours after he adjusted my large back filling on the opposite side of his 5-unit bridge and my jaw was all the way to the left and I had extreme pain.  As though someone had kicked me in the face.  I feel the tooth was taken down too low (filed down) with the adjustment on the filling when he adjusted on July 31st and my bite was not checked after the adjustment to see if it affected the bridge height. Or, the root canals failed (no follow up) and my teeth were raising out of my jaw bone from infection.

 

 I am concerned that the Dr. Kaplan did not call me in for a follow up at 6 – 8 weeks.  They did not even look at the implant after I told them it was exposed and that I was having sensation and some pain there.   Dr. Kaplan then had the nerve to suggest bone grafting this area?    Too many dentists have told me that trying to place bone in this area now is not viable. 

 

 Another dentist in Fort Lauderdale, who asked me not to name him, personally knows Dr. Kaplan (he went to school with him).  He was surprised at the implant used in the back (it is shallow) and the positioning of each implant with respect to restoration.  He said, “Kaplan should have known better with positioning the implants.  He also said that Blake had no business even working in my mouth with such a large and bold restoration – you make less than $40,000/year.  He has enough clients in Palm Beach that there is no need to be taking advantage of you and putting you in this position.  This work should never have been done to you.

 

Dentistry, unfortunately, is a business and you should not forget that.  Your potential future jaw problems were not the reason for this work.  Try and consider what happened a bad business decision and try and get on with your life.  I am so sorry this was done to you; you did not deserve it”.